By allowing people to participate online in an anonymous way it can allow people to have a whole new experience as they are no longer inhibited by the constraints of their personal ‘norms’ while their personal identity and privacy is protected. This can be as simple as pretending to be a male while playing a video game that would only entice ridicule if the other players knew you were a female or chatting with people under a completely untrue alter ego. By not having to disclose who you really are it can allow people to act in a truly uninhibited way that can be presented either positively or negatively without consequences. I believe that people have learned to love online interactions mostly due to the anonymity associated with it and when Blizzard, for example, tries to remove this it is obvious to me that the strong reactions that were produced are proof to this. People have come to enjoy and also feel a sense of entitlement to this personal freedom that they feel through online anonymity and I believe that it would be unreasonable to take this away.
Wednesday, 20 April 2011
The implications of online anonymity
Would you rob a bank or steal money from someone on the street? Would you verbally abuse someone who has an opposing belief to you? Would you expose someone’s deepest darkest secrets, knowing that they could have tremendous damage to that person? I believe that these are all logical questions that can easily be answered by most people saying no. What if you were given these same scenarios but were told that no one would ever know it was you who did it? This sense of anonymity is sure to make some people second guess their initial reactions and reconsider their actions knowing that they won’t be held accountable. This is what is happening in online chat rooms, forums, games or any other area where online interactions are to be had. Because of the anonymity that we are provided with it is allowing us to act in ill-mannered way without consequences. Granted, all online interactions are not like this but it is becoming all too common that we see trolls in chat rooms and random forum postings. As described in the New York Times article, “The Trolls among Us”, Trolls are someone who intentionally disrupts online communities, while using their online anonymity as their shield. They deceive people by employing pseudo-naïve tactics that trick people into responding to stupid questions and following up with endless ridicule and harassment to the members that are involved. Because of the anonymity given online it allows people to act in ways that would not be socially acceptable but have just become a part of online life. The reason for this is that anonymity has essentially come to mean that you are unaccountable for your actions as they cannot be traced back to you. The online world is a world with few consequences and those that are in place are easily avoided by simply creating a new user name or logon id it seems like. I think that online anonymity and negative behaviors will always go hand in hand as people have come to believe that anonymity equals unaccountability.
What can we do?
I do not believe that there is much that we can do about the negative interactions that are experienced online. As I mentioned, Blizzard tried to change this by implementing Real ID to better its tarnished reputation, but the response received by this made the transition impossible. People have adapted to the anonymity given online and are going to be reluctant to give it up in any community that does not currently enforce any Real ID type of profile. People can use the internet to escape their day to day lives and act in completely uncharacteristic ways and I think that this kind of freedom will be extremely difficult to take away as it is not available in any other aspect of our lives. I do not think that taking away online anonymity is the solution to this problem but more so, better monitoring is. With that being said I do realize how incredibly difficult this will be as there are millions of interactions occurring each and every day but if we can all take it upon ourselves to monitor our own behaviors and those around us, online interactions could be much more pleasant than they are today. Just because our identity isn’t known doesn’t mean we should have the right to act like complete idiots, we need to be accountable for all of our actions, not just the ones with our names on it.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)